Various NBA executives and coaches were polled this month by Tim Bontemps of ESPN, questioned on which sophomore player they’d rather have: Ben Simmons, Donovan Mitchell, Jayson Tatum or De’Aaron Fox.
All four players are considered to be among the league’s best young talent, but ranking the players is tougher than what it seems. The polling from the ESPN article largely echoed the results of the 2018 Rookie of the Year Award race, with Simmons ranking first, Mitchell second, Tatum third, and Fox fourth. Simmons received as many first-place votes (nine) as the other three players did combined.
“Simmons is in his own class,” an Eastern Conference executive told Bontemps, “because of his size and passing ability, plus his defense. Having the ability to control the game at both ends is really valuable.”
Of the four players, Simmons is the only talent without a reliable jumpshot. The thought of him one day having a consistent jumper — in addition to his already mesmerizing passing, rebounding and driving abilities — could strike fear in teams around the league.
However, not all of those polled agreed with Simmons being one of the top choices of the four players.
“Simmons doesn’t shoot,” one West executive said. “If you’re a championship-caliber team, non-shooters can’t be on the floor.”
“He’s really f—ing good,” another said. “But where do you play him?”
Here are some more odds and ends from around the basketball world:
- NBA legend Alonzo Mourning is among 11 world class basketball personalities that make up FIBA Hall of Fame’s 2019 class of inductees, FIBA announced this week. Mourning joins Janeth Arcain (Brazil), Bogdan Tanjevic (Montenegro) and others to be inducted, having helped Team USA win the FIBA Basketball World Cup in 1994. He also went on to help win a gold medal at the Sydney Olympics in 2000.
- LSU expects to lose 19-year-old forward Naz Reid for the NBA Draft this spring, Adam Zagoria of Zagsblog.com writes. “Yeah, we’re expecting to lose him,” LSU assistant Greg Heiar admitted last week. “If you’re a top-20 pick in the draft, you need to go. You need to go. It’s what his dream is so we want him to chase his dream. You never want to hold a young man back.” Along with Reid, another LSU player who could garner professional interest in the coming months is Tremont Waters, an improved 5’11” point guard with impressive handles and court vision.
- Free agent Rob Gray has agreed to a deal in France with JL Bourg, according to Sportando. Gray started the 2018/19 season with Fort Wayne in the NBA G League, with their campaign officially coming to an end this past week. Gray played summer league and later joined the Rockets for training camp last fall, getting waived before the season began.
choosing whatever player entirely depends on the team’s current system/coach – donovan mitchells been on fire, put him on the warriors and his numbers become pedestrian
I’m pretty sure the idea was objectively which player are you taking.
I’ll take Fox over Tatum.
Simmons was a true build-around. He was lucky to get taken by a team that lets him do what he wants, because he is reinventing… whatever position it is he plays. No grumpy established vets saying what are you doing rook, no strict coach wanting it his way.
Only Tatum has been in a situation requiring a lot of adaption, with mixed results.
Last year I would have said:
1)Simmons 2) JT 3) Mitchell 4) Fox
This year I say:
1) Simmons 2) Fox 3) Mitchell 4) JT
I mean with Simmons is not even close, he is a superstar, a class way over the other 3, can’t ever compare them.
But definitely Fox has surprised me this year, improved a lot.
Mitchell still is just a volume shooter, not even an effective one.
JT is intriguing, but ain’t working in Boston, so I hope he gets traded to NOLA or Kyrie leaves, so he can have a bigger role & we can see what he can truly do, potentially is better than Mitchell & Fox.