There was widespread skepticism during the 2024 offseason about the Cavaliers' decision to continue moving forward with their four-player core of Donovan Mitchell, Darius Garland, Jarrett Allen, and Evan Mobley after the team struggled to get past the upstart Magic in round one of the playoffs and then was defeated soundly in round two by the eventual champion Celtics.
Garland was coming off an injury-plagued down year, while Allen had been unable to suit up for the Cavs' final eight playoff games due to a rib issue. There was a sense among many league observers that Cleveland would be better off trading one or both players to better balance the roster, given the overlap in skill sets between Garland and Mitchell in the backcourt and Allen and Mobley up front.
But president of basketball operations Koby Altman and his front office decided to double down on the quartet, signing three of them to new contract extensions in 2024 (the fourth, Garland, was already on a long-term deal). Rather than shaking up the roster, the Cavs made their most significant offseason move on the sidelines, where new head coach Kenny Atkinson replaced J.B. Bickerstaff.
The Cavs responded by making Altman look like a genius from day one of the 2024/25 season. They raced out to a 15-0 start and was 56-10 in mid-March before stumbling a little in the season's final weeks, going 8-8 down the stretch. Atkinson's impact was immediately evident, as a Cleveland team that ranked 16th in offensive rating (114.7) in 2023/24 put up the league's No. 1 mark (121.0) in '24/25 without sacrificing anything on defense. The club finished eighth in defensive rating, with Mobley earning Defensive Player of the Year honors.
Although the Cavs essentially didn't make any veteran roster additions ahead of the 2024/25 season, Ty Jerome returned from a season-ending ankle injury and made a greater impact than the team could've hoped for, averaging a career-high 12.5 points per game on .516/.439/.872 shooting and finishing the season as a Sixth Man of the Year finalist. Outside of Jerome and trade-deadline acquisition De'Andre Hunter though, this was essentially the same group that had won 48 games a year earlier.
Atkinson was named Coach of the Year for turning the Cavs into a 64-win team, and after demolishing the Heat in the most one-sided playoff series in NBA history, they appeared poised for a deep postseason run. Instead, they once again fell to the eventual Eastern champs in round two -- this time around, it was the Pacers who eliminated them in five games.
Cleveland was banged up in the second round, with Garland, Mobley, and Hunter each missing at least one game while Mitchell battled calf and ankle problems. But it would be hard to say definitively that they would've beaten the Pacers with better health luck. And even if they believe that to be true, the Cavs will face some difficult roster decisions in the near future, with their team salary poised to soar past the second tax apron in 2025/26.
Since the NBA's current Collective Bargaining Agreement went into effect, teams have exhibited a reluctance to operate above the second apron for more than a year or two at a time, having been willing to surpass that threshold only if they feel that they're capable of contending for a title.
The Cavs' 64 regular season wins suggest they're legitimate contenders, but their inability to get past the second round of the playoffs casts doubt on that belief. With massive tax penalties and major roster restrictions looming, the front office will have to think long and hard about whether it makes sense to run it back once more with the current group or whether it's time to entertain more significant roster changes.
The Cavaliers' Offseason Plan
Mitchell, who finished fifth in MVP voting this past season, and Mobley, a first-time Defensive Player of the Year in his age-23 season, are clearly the long-term cornerstones the Cavaliers plan to build around. They won't be available via trade this offseason. But the same can't be said about Garland and Allen. A May report indicated that the Cavs appear more open than in the past to listening to inquiries for those two other members of their "core four."
Unlock Subscriber-Exclusive Articles Like This One With a Trade Rumors Front Office Subscription
- Access weekly subscriber-only articles by Luke Adams
- Join exclusive weekly live chats with Arthur Hill
- Remove ads and support our writers.